Contract Trucking Rates Rise Despite a Sharp Drop in Freight Volumes
Staff
Published October 12, 2026


A nearly 28% year-over-year decline in August contract freight volumes highlights the growing gap between rising trucking rates and underlying market demand, according to data from U.S. Bank and DAT Freight & Analytics.
Rising Rates Do Not Necessarily Signal a Stronger Market
The U.S. trucking industry is experiencing a growing disconnect between freight volumes and transportation rates, creating a more complicated picture for carriers, drivers, and shippers. Although contract rates have continued to increase, the volume of freight moving through the market has weakened significantly.
According to the latest U.S. Bank and DAT Freight & Analytics payments index, published this month, stronger rates may be concealing ongoing weaknesses in the broader freight market.
The report highlights several important developments:
Contract freight rates increased by $0.20 per mile, reaching $2.39 per mile in August compared with the same month a year earlier.
Contract freight volumes declined by nearly 28% year over year, indicating that higher rates have not been accompanied by stronger shipping activity.
Market analysts caution that improving pricing conditions should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of a healthy recovery in freight demand.
The report emphasizes that rate stability and market stability are not the same thing. Until freight volumes begin to recover and establish a more consistent pattern, stronger rates alone will provide only a partial view of the industry's condition.
For trucking companies, this distinction is particularly important. Higher revenue per mile can help offset operating expenses, but lower freight availability may leave trucks idle, reduce utilization, and make it more difficult to maintain consistent cash flow.
Dry Van Contract Rates Rise Far Above Seasonal Norms
The divergence between rates and freight volumes is especially visible in the dry van segment. According to DAT data, dry van contract rates climbed approximately 14% between January and September 2026, significantly exceeding the seasonal increases typically seen during this period.
Forecasts cited in the report suggest that contract rates could rise by approximately 19% over the full 2026 calendar year, assuming the projected increase through December materializes.
This performance stands in sharp contrast to historical trends. Data dating back to 2010 show that contract rates have typically increased by around 3% over a 12-month period, according to a spokesperson for DAT, a freight analytics and forecasting company.
Only a few recent periods have produced similarly dramatic gains. During the exceptional freight market conditions of 2020 and 2021, contract rates rose by approximately 18% and 17%, respectively.
However, the current situation differs from a conventional demand-driven recovery. Instead of strong freight volumes pushing prices higher, today's rate increases are developing alongside weaker shipping activity and mounting pressure on trucking capacity.
DAT representatives have also pointed to a timing difference between the spot and contract markets. Spot rates have eased from their summer levels, while contract rates continue adjusting to earlier market conditions.
This difference matters because the two pricing models respond to market changes at different speeds. Spot rates tend to react more quickly to immediate shifts in available trucks and freight demand, whereas contract rates generally reflect longer-term agreements between carriers and shippers.
As a result, contract pricing can continue rising even when conditions in the spot market begin to cool.
Regulatory Changes and Legal Developments Add Pressure
The trucking industry is also navigating a more demanding regulatory environment. Stricter federal enforcement standards and compliance requirements are adding to the challenges facing carriers and professional drivers.
Stay Informed
Get freight market insights delivered to your inbox
Join industry professionals receiving our weekly analysis.
Recent developments involving commercial driver's license requirements, English-language proficiency enforcement, and efforts to identify potentially fraudulent CDL holders have increased attention on driver qualifications and regulatory compliance.
While these measures are intended to strengthen safety and enforcement, they may also affect the availability of eligible drivers and the operating capacity of some trucking companies. Carriers must therefore balance compliance costs, staffing requirements, and operational efficiency while continuing to meet customer expectations.
Legal developments are contributing to the uncertainty as well. Industry leaders have discussed the potential implications of the Supreme Court's Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II decision, particularly its relevance to certain carriers, freight brokers, and questions surrounding safety responsibilities.
Together, these developments are creating an environment in which access to qualified drivers, compliant equipment, and reliable transportation capacity can have a greater influence on operating costs and freight pricing.
The precise impact will vary by carrier, fleet size, business model, and the way individual companies adapt to changing requirements.
Record-High Diesel Prices Put Additional Strain on Carriers
Fuel expenses remain another major source of pressure. Elevated diesel prices are increasing the cost of operating trucks, making route planning, fuel management, and load selection increasingly important for carriers trying to protect already narrow profit margins.
Smaller trucking companies are particularly vulnerable because they often have fewer financial resources to absorb sudden increases in fuel and maintenance expenses.
Patrick Pretorius, DAT's general manager of the shipper segment, noted in a statement accompanying the U.S. Bank and DAT report that higher fuel costs can push smaller, lower-margin carriers out of the market. Their departure can further reduce available capacity and add pressure to an already constrained driver supply.
Fuel expenses are also changing how carriers approach individual loads. Deadhead miles, which occur when trucks travel without freight, become more expensive when diesel prices rise. Carriers consequently have stronger incentives to avoid inefficient repositioning trips and prioritize loads that offer better mileage, predictable routes, and more dependable revenue.
An October market update from C.H. Robinson Worldwide highlighted additional limitations of fuel surcharges. Although these charges can help carriers recover some of their increased diesel expenses, they may not fully compensate for idle time, longer-than-planned routes, weather-related disruptions, or the specialized operating requirements of temperature-controlled freight.
This creates an important distinction between recovering fuel costs and protecting overall profitability. A load may include a fuel surcharge but still generate disappointing returns if a truck spends too much time waiting, travels additional miles, or encounters delays that reduce its productive hours.
Contract Freight Offers Stability, but Route Efficiency Matters
Carriers operating under contracted freight agreements generally have mechanisms for recovering fuel expenses through fuel surcharges billed to shippers. These arrangements can provide a degree of protection against diesel price fluctuations, depending on the terms of the contract and the surcharge formula being used.
However, fuel recovery does not eliminate every financial risk. Deviations from planned routes, unexpected delays, empty miles, and inconsistent shipment schedules can still increase operating expenses and weaken margins.
For this reason, carriers are placing greater emphasis on consistent freight volumes, dependable shipping partners, and efficient route planning. Repeat business and predictable freight movements can help companies reduce unnecessary mileage, improve equipment utilization, and make better use of available drivers.
Shippers also have an important role to play. More reliable forecasts, realistic pickup and delivery schedules, and better coordination with transportation providers can help reduce inefficiencies throughout the supply chain.
In an environment where operating costs remain high, the quality and consistency of freight can be just as important as the rate paid per mile. A higher-paying load is not always the most profitable option if it involves excessive empty miles, long waiting periods, or significant operational complications.
Dry Van Rates Could Continue Increasing Through 2027
Ongoing capacity pressures are helping push contract rates higher, even as freight volumes remain weak. According to a September DAT Signal report, dry van contract rates were projected to reach $2.55 per mile by December 2026, with further monthly increases anticipated throughout 2027.
These projections point to the possibility of continued pricing pressure in the contract market. However, forecasts should not be treated as guaranteed outcomes. Actual rates will depend on freight demand, available trucking capacity, fuel costs, regulatory developments, and broader economic conditions.
For carriers, the key challenge will be determining whether higher rates can compensate for lower shipment volumes and rising expenses. Companies that manage costs carefully, minimize empty miles, maintain reliable customer relationships, and monitor profitability at the load level may be better positioned to navigate the changing environment.
Shippers, meanwhile, may need to prepare for higher transportation costs when renewing contracts or securing dependable capacity. Planning ahead and maintaining strong relationships with carriers could become increasingly important if the supply of available trucks tightens further.
Ultimately, the trucking market's recovery cannot be measured by rates alone. A more sustainable improvement would require stronger and more consistent freight volumes, healthier carrier margins, and a better balance between transportation demand and available capacity.
Until those conditions emerge, the widening gap between rising contract rates and declining freight volumes will remain one of the most important signals to watch across the U.S. trucking industry.